
Match lowest price option
It is a hassle, especially if you have many items, to know whether your listed prices are in line with others who might also be selling the same game(s). An example is Amazon's "Match lowest Price" option for sellers. It keeps prices in check while also helping to curb artificially inflating game values.

Messaging system via website
We need to be able to communicate directly through the website. The e-mail messaging system gets lost with the hundreds of other e-mails I recieve. Plus it'd be a lot easier to organize and go through the messages and whatnot

Add marketplace features to the current PriceCharting mobile app
It would be useful to be able to view the marketplace through the mobile app. I would especially be interested in features similar to the eBay mobile app. Mainly ones, such as getting a notification on my phone when an item sells. This would allow me to potentially ship sold items more quickly.

Filter marketplace listings to see only those with photos
Let me see only listings with actual photos of the item instead of stock photos.

Fix the NEW Sealed $ = it is lower than "loose" in Dreamcast
Your pricing on some rare games makes no sense - for instance Bang-O NEW sealed copy is less than a loose price. Obviously this makes no sense and your system should recognize this. Don't use any price would be better - although I found examples offered on games on Amazon. This is a bad flaw, and really hurts the credability of your site.

We are monitoring prices on a daily basis to remove junk listings (the root cause) and fix price inversions like you mentioned. We want to fix these whenever possible.
Tig makes a very good point though about games with old sales data.
The last sale might have been years ago. We can either use that as the price, or we can extrapolate how much the game might be worth today instead. The 2nd option is fraught with inaccuracies so we decided to go with option 1 and show users the sales history.

Add support for CGC half grades (0.5 increments) for comic books, at least 8.5
Please add support for CGC half grades (0.5 increments) for comic books. At least add 8.5.
The price difference of a half grade can be significant.
Customer support service by UserEcho